Short answer: there are three ways to make a memory book. A paper fill-in book (€20–€50) is the loveliest thing to hold, but it usually ends up half empty. A photo book you put together yourself (€30–€80 per volume) gives the best-looking result, but each book costs you an evening or more. A digital memory book is the easiest to keep up, carries on growing after the first year and can be shared with family. Which one suits you comes down to one question: how much effort does it take you to keep it going?
Because that is almost always where it goes wrong. Nearly everyone starts a memory book, and most of them are sitting half empty on a shelf a year later. The photos never got printed, the prompts felt too limiting, and meanwhile the unsorted pictures keep piling up on your phone.
Below are all three options side by side: what they cost in money, what they cost in time, and where each of them tends to fall apart in real life.
Option 1: The paper fill-in baby book
You buy a paper baby book at a baby shop or online, and fill it in step by step in the months after the birth: birth details, first smile, first words, first steps.
Advantages
Tangible and emotionally precious. A physical object with handwriting, stuck-in photos and real memories feels different from a screen. Your child can hold it as an adult, leaf through it, rest it on their lap.
No technology needed. No app, no account, no internet connection. You don't have to worry about the platform shutting down or your password expiring. The book is simply there.
A popular new baby gift. A good baby book, from brands such as Petit Monkey, Studio Stationery or Nuuna, is a much-loved present and looks beautiful.
Disadvantages
Most books stay empty. Life gets too busy, the prompts feel too limiting, and the photos you want to stick in were never printed. After the first year, most baby books barely get touched.
Only one copy, with no backup. If the book gets lost, damaged, or ruined by damp or fire, everything is gone. That is the risk you accept if you choose paper alone.
You can't share it from a distance. Grandparents in another town only see the book when they visit in person. The timeline you have built up, with its context and stories, doesn't come across in a handful of loose photos.
It stops after the first year. Most baby books are designed for age 0–1, or 0–3 at most. What do you do after that?
Option 2: Putting together your own photo book
With services such as Albelli, Photobox or Cheerz you upload photos, choose a layout, write captions and order a printed copy.
Advantages
Entirely to your own taste. You decide which photos go in, which words and in what order. The result is a personal, one-of-a-kind book.
A professional finish. The print quality of photo book services has improved a lot in recent years. It is something to be proud of and to keep.
You can order several copies. You can have the book printed more than once: for the grandparents, for the other parent if you're co-parenting, and for yourself.
Disadvantages
It takes a lot of time. Putting together a good photo book takes hours, sometimes a whole day. Choosing photos, sorting them, writing captions, picking a layout. Most parents keep putting it off, so the book never happens, or only years later when the story behind each photo has long been forgotten.
Your memories are scattered. The photos you need are spread across your phone, iCloud, WhatsApp groups and maybe an old device. Before you can start on the book, you first have to gather everything together.
Grandparents wait a year. A photo book is an end product. You can't share it halfway through the year, while grandparents often want to hear how things are going every week.
You can't search it. A printed book has no search. You can't filter on "all the swimming pool photos" or "all the drawings from Year 2". It is a static object.
Option 3: A digital memory app
A dedicated app works differently from leaving your photos in iCloud or Google Photos. Those services are built for storage; they don't tell your child's story. We wrote earlier about why WhatsApp and standalone photo storage aren't enough.
Advantages
Always with you, easy to keep up. When your child does something funny, reaches a milestone or draws a picture, you open the app and capture it. No hurdle, no planning needed.
Grandparents can follow along in real time. Through a tidy timeline rather than a stream of loose WhatsApp messages. In Ouderliefde, grandparents view everything through their own secure link, which only your family gets and which you can revoke at any time.
Grows with your child. From the very first photo to the first school report, from reception class drawings to a letter you write for later. The app grows with your child: one place, with no end point.
Automatic backup. Your memories don't live on one physical object that can be lost or damaged. Cloud storage takes care of the backup.
Works for co-parenting. Both parents can add to the same diary from their own homes. With a paper book that simply isn't possible. We wrote about how co-parents can keep their child's memories together.
Disadvantages
Not tangible. A screen isn't a book. Scrolling a digital timeline feels different from holding a physical object your child can keep later on. For parents who care about having something in their hands, that is a real loss.
You depend on the platform. If the app shuts down or the company goes bust, you might lose access. Choose an app that lets you export your data, so your memories stay yours whatever happens to the platform.
It needs a habit. If you don't look at it for weeks, memories slip away. The bar is low, but it isn't zero.
Digital as the foundation, paper as the extra
For many parents a hybrid approach works best. You use a digital app as the living diary: the place where everything comes together, gets shared and is kept safe. Once a year, or at a special moment, you order a printed photo book of the highlights.
That way you have a living timeline that is updated right after each moment, and a physical object to keep and pass on.
That is also the thinking behind the timeline in Ouderliefde: a digital memory archive your child can leaf through one day when they're older, and from which you can export a selection for a printed book at any time.
Which approach suits whom
Choose the paper baby book if: you enjoy writing by hand, you like keeping memories slowly and deliberately, and you accept that sharing it will be limited.
Choose the DIY photo book if: you have the energy to put everything together once a year, a beautiful end result matters to you, and you want to order several copies for family.
Choose a digital app if: you want your memories kept up as you go, you want to share with the grandparents in real time, you're co-parenting, or you want to keep memories for the whole of your child's childhood (and beyond).
Try Ouderliefde for free
Every new Ouderliefde account starts with 7 days of free Premium (normally €5.49 a month). No payment details needed, as the trial simply ends by itself.
Sign up here: Create a free account →.